1. Peppermint Pig and Gift

If your heart beats for animals and thrifting, look no further than Cincinnati’s own Peppermint Pig Thrift & Gift. This unique establishment seamlessly combines the charm of a thrift store with the mission of an animal rescue. As a registered 501(c)(3), it relies on dedicated volunteers to operate, and every single cent they earn goes to support the Peppermint Pig Animal Rescue.

This animal rescue is committed to saving the lives of mostly dogs rescued from high-kill shelters, open intake shelters, and regions with alarmingly high euthanasia rates. They are often faced with daunting veterinary bills, sometimes exceeding $10,000 per month, covering procedures, medications, and rehabilitation, all while striving to keep adoption fees affordable.

By purchasing from this thrift store, which offers a wide range of items including clothing, books, jewelry, household goods, furniture, holiday items, and small appliances, you contribute directly to these crucial vet bills and help find loving homes for their dogs and cats. Don’t forget, you’re welcome to bring your own furry friends along when you shop!

Location: Cherry Grove

2. Pixel 19 Vintage

For the ultimate vintage clothing thrift store experience in Cincinnati, Pixel 19 Vintage is your go-to destination. This sprawling 10,000-square-foot space is a treasure trove of diverse vintage finds, with price tags as low as $10. Whether you’re hunting for vintage or retro apparel, hippie or biker vibes, you’ll find it here.

Their inventory spans clothing primarily from the 1980s, reaching as far back as the 1920s, alongside accessories, shoes, art, lighting, decor, sculptures, furniture, and a trove of music and film memorabilia. Every item is meticulously hand-picked.

While the store is open to the public, it also caters to customers, stylists, vintage dealers, global collectors, and corporate clients. Fun fact: You might have spotted them featured on an episode of American Pickers.

Please note that they’re closed on Wednesdays and Saturdays, but you can make appointments for buying and selling on all other days.

Location: Lower Price Hill

3. Scrap It Up Second Hand Store

For those seeking a spark of creativity, Scrap It Up is Cincinnati’s creative reuse center and a haven for the artistically inclined. They specialize in gently used art materials and upcycled crafting supplies, waiting to embark on new artistic journeys with artists, teachers, children, parents, and students.

This non-profit reuse center, run by women, is on a mission to promote sustainability by diverting art and craft items away from the waste stream, all while offering affordable supplies for creative projects. They are open for business from Wednesday to Saturday, and donations require an appointment.

Location: Pleasant Ridge

4. Talk of the Town

If you’re longing for one-of-a-kind costumes and vintage garments, Talk of the Town will transport you on a nostalgic journey. This unique establishment is open only on weekends, so make sure to mark your calendar.

Their top floor is a treasure trove of costumes, while the main floor boasts high-quality vintage items spanning various eras. With a plethora of retro prints and eye-catching pieces, be prepared to spend several delightful hours browsing through their collections.

Location: Reading

5. New2You One-Stop-Shop

For those who love the thrill of the hunt but aren’t quite sure what they’re looking for, New2You is one of Cincinnati, Ohio’s premier second-hand stores. Their diverse inventory includes gently-used clothing, accessories, shoes, jewelry, housewares, furniture, electronics, records, games, books, VHS tapes, CDs, appliances, artwork, gifts, and much more.

This volunteer-run non-profit shop started as a “biznistry” in 2006, combining business and ministry outreach efforts of Peoples Church Cincinnati. Keep an eye out for their jaw-dropping 50% off sales to score incredible discounts.

Location: Corryville

6. Casablanca Vintage

For a genuine yesteryear shopping experience, Casablanca Vintage stands as one of Cincinnati’s top thrift shops. Over the past 35 years, they have been offering men’s and women’s clothing and accessories spanning from the 1920s to the 1990s, and you might even stumble upon items dating back to the 1800s.

Whether you’re in search of costumes for theater and film, attire for a themed party, or day-to-day vintage fashion, you’ll find it here. Their well-organized inventory includes both high-end and affordable items.

Casablanca Vintage also offers options for buying, selling, and renting, and they enthusiastically collaborate with fashion designers and stylists. This queer co-owned shop is also home to Awesome Time Shoe and Leather Repair, a reliable shoe repair service.

Location: Northside

7. Legacies Upscale Resale Furniture

As one of Cincinnati’s premier second-hand furniture stores, Legacies Upscale Resale is your destination for high-end designer jewelry, textiles, home decor, crystal, china, furniture, and art—all at significant savings.

They proudly feature brand names like Haviland, Ethan Allen, and Stiffel. This primarily volunteer-run establishment donates all its profits to the Cancer Support Community of Greater Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky. For over 25 years, they have been instrumental in providing free services such as workshops, classes, and support groups to cancer patients and their families.

Donation and consignment opportunities are available by appointment.

Location: Oakley

8. St. Vincent de Paul Thrift Store

With several thrift stores in the Cincinnati, Ohio area, St. Vincent de Paul remains a popular choice among secondhand shoppers. Your purchases directly contribute to funding the faith-based organization’s invaluable neighborly support services, which encompass food and nutrition programs, health and wellness education, homelessness prevention, and fulfilling basic needs.

These thrift stores offer a blend of modern and vintage clothing, shoes, accessories, books, housewares, furniture, and holiday items. Keep an eye out for surprise 50% off sales—it might be your lucky day!

Locations: West End | Beechmont Ave | Winton Place | Westwood | Colerain Ave | Evendale

9. Play it Again Sports

With locations across the country, including three thrift stores in Cincinnati, Play it Again Sports is the ultimate destination for sporty secondhand shopping. The smartest way to dive into any sport or activity is by opting for gently-used sports gear and fitness equipment, ranging from disc golf supplies and free weights to bikes, skis, ice skates, and more.

Whatever your sporting aspirations, they have the gear to help you achieve them. And if you discover that rugby isn’t quite your game, you don’t even need an appointment to get cash outright or trade-in value for your equipment.

Locations: Groesbeck | Springdale | Landen

10. Indigo Hippo

Attention all art enthusiasts! When it comes to creatively named resale shops in Cincinnati, Indigo Hippo reigns supreme. This 501(c)(3) nonprofit is committed to making creativity accessible, offering pay-what-you-can pricing for their creative materials. Each item bears a tag with a range of prices, allowing you to choose what you pay.

Their inventory includes essentials for drawing and illustration, knitting and yarn, jewelry and beads, print and printmaking, fabric and sewing, stamps and stickers, crafts and random fun, paper and office supplies, books and picture frames, floral and containers, tile and wood, tools and hardware, and kits.

Indigo Hippo frequently collaborates with local organizations and provides free supplies to those in need. They are open from Thursday to Saturday, and anyone can schedule an appointment to donate or volunteer.

Location: Over-the-Rhine

11. Astute Furnishings

When it comes to decking out your living space, Astute Furnishings offers an unparalleled selection of furniture, decorative decor, lighting, and art. This Cincinnati thrift store boasts an eclectic range, from mid-century and vintage to art deco, antique, and modern pieces.

In business since 1993, they hold the distinction of being Cincinnati’s oldest furniture consignment business. Competitive pricing and convenient consignment opportunities are part of their appeal. If you can’t visit the showroom in person, they also offer an online shopping option.

Location: Oakley Square